Advertise with the Daily Report
  Law.com Home Newswire LawJobs CLE Center LawCatalog Our Sites Advertise  
An ALM web site
Daily Report

Welcome
My Account
7:09 PM EST
Friday, November 20, 2009

Get premium access 30-day trial
Subscribe now for under $1 a day
Receive free daily headlines
Subscribe to the Daily Report
Search Site:       News Articles     Court Opinions     Court Calendars     Public Notices     Consumer Alerts      help Daily Report news feed
Multimedia & Photos

Who should be the next justice?

Gov. Sonny Perdue will soon get to fill a seat on the Supreme Court of Georgia being vacated by Chief Justice Leah Ward Sears, who is retiring.

The following list of nominees has been submitted to the governor’s Judicial Nominating Commission, which will recommend up to five names for his consideration. If you were the governor, who would you choose?

You may vote only once, but you can check back whenever you want to see what our readers are saying.  Scroll to the bottom to see the results.

Welcome.

Samuel D. Ozburn

Samuel D. Ozburn

Alcovy Judicial Circuit Superior Court Judge

Nominated by State Sen. John Douglas, R-Social Circle (February 12)



Go to results

Garland R. Hunt

Garland R. Hunt

State Board of Pardons and Paroles Member

Nominated by political consultant Tim Echols (December 26)



Go to results

Benjamin W. Studdard III

Benjamin W. Studdard III

Henry County State Court Chief Judge

Nominated by Mercer Law Professors Jack L. Sammons (December 19) and Joseph E. Claxton (January 12)



Go to results

Patrick H. Head

Patrick H. Head

Cobb County District Attorney

Nominated by former DeKalb County District Attorney J. Tom Morgan (April 16)



Go to results

C. Wilson DuBose

C. Wilson DuBose

Georgia Public Defender Standards Council Chairman

Nominated by himself (April 29) and Atlanta lawyer Terrence L. Croft of King & Croft (May 27)



Go to results

Thomas D. Harper

Thomas D. Harper

Atlanta insurance defense lawyer at Harper, Walden & Craig

Nominated by Athens lawyer Craig C. Avery (May 22)



Go to results

Craig L. Schwall Sr.

Craig L. Schwall Sr.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge

Nominated by Troutman Sanders partner Mark H. Cohen (May 22)



Go to results

William M. Ray II

William M. Ray II

Gwinnett County Superior Court Judge

Nominated by Augusta lawyer David P. Dekle (May 22)



Go to results

J. David McDade

J. David McDade

Douglas County District Attorney

Nominated by Blue Ridge Judicial Circuit District Attorney Garry T. Moss (May 26)



Go to results

James P. Kelly III

James P. Kelly III

Atlanta solo practitioner

Nominated by Atlanta lawyer Harry W. MacDougald of Caldwell & Watson (May 26)



Go to results

Stephen B. Farrow

Stephen B. Farrow

State Transportation Board Member

Nominated James H. Bisson III, a colleague at the North Georgia firm of Minor, Bell & Neal (May 27)



Go to results

Mary E. Staley

Mary E. Staley

Cobb County Superior Court Judge

Nominated by herself (May 28)



Go to results

Peggy H. Walker

Peggy H. Walker

Douglas County Juvenile Court Judge

Nominated herself (May 9)



Go to results

Cynthia J. Becker

Cynthia J. Becker

DeKalb County Superior Court Judge

Nominated by Robert F. Dallas, director of Governor’s Office of Highway Safety (May 28)



Go to results

M. Yvette Miller

M. Yvette Miller

Chief Judge, Court of Appeals of Georgia

Nominated by Benjamin A. Davis Jr. (May 28)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

David E. Nahmias

David E. Nahmias

U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Georgia

Nominated by David J. Burge (May 28), Frank C. Jones (May 29), Jeffrey S. Cashdan (May 29), Larry D. Thompson (June 1)



Go to results

Zena E. McClain

Zena E. McClain

Savannah attorney

Nominated herself (May 29)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

Kenneth L. Shigley

Kenneth L. Shigley

Chambers, Aholt & Rickard

Nominated by George M. Weaver (May 29)



Go to results

Bruce M. Edenfield

Bruce M. Edenfield

Dahlonega attorney

Nominated by Robert E. Hicks of McKenna Long & Aldridge (June 1)



Go to results

James R. Osborne

James R. Osborne

Paulding County Superior Court Judge

Nominated by W. Thomas Cable of Talley, Richardson & Cable (June 1)



Go to results

Michael P. Boggs

Michael P. Boggs

Waycross Judicial Circuit Superior Court Judge

Nominated himself (June 1)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

Stephen Louis A. Dillard

Stephen Louis A. Dillard

James, Bates, Pope & Spivey

Nominated by state Sen. Cecil Staton (June 1)



Go to results

Jeannette L. Little

Jeannette L. Little

Troup County State Court Judge

Nominated by state Rep. Randy Nix (June 1)



Go to results

John K. Larkins Jr.

John K. Larkins Jr.

Partner, Chilivis, Cochran, Larkins & Bever

Nominated by John K. Larkins III (June 1)



Go to results

Barry A. Fleming

Barry A. Fleming

Partner, Fulcher Hagler

Nominated by Brian Epps of Kilpatrick Stockton (June 1)



Go to results

Richard S. “Rick” Thompson

Richard S. “Rick” Thompson

Partner, Drew Eckl & Farnham

Nominated by Drew Eckl partner John G. Blackmon Jr. (June 1)

Declined the nomination



Go to results

David Ralston

David Ralston

Attorney and State Representative, R-Blue Ridge

Nominated by State Rep. Doug Collins (June 2)



Go to results

William G. Hamrick III

William G. Hamrick III

State Senator, R-Carrollton

Nominated by state Sen. Ross Tolleson, R-Perry (May 28)



Go to results

Joshua C. Bell

Joshua C. Bell

Bainbridge lawyer

Nominated by Damon E. Elmore, vice president at NAPA Rayloc (June 2)



Go to results

J. Robert Persons

J. Robert Persons

Atlanta civil defense lawyer at Smith Moore Leatherwood

Nominated by Atlanta lawyers W. Seaborn Jones, C. David Butler and Paul M. Talmadge Jr. (June 2)



Go to results

Dawn H. Taylor

Dawn H. Taylor

Gwinnett County Assistant District Attorney

Nominated by Stuart E. Walker of Martin Snow in Macon (June 3)



Go to results

Christopher J. McFadden

Christopher J. McFadden

Decatur appellate lawyer

Nominated by Atlanta lawyer Guy E. Davis Jr. (June 3)



Go to results

Steven K. Leibel

Steven K. Leibel

Dahlonega personal injury lawyer

Nominated by Atlanta lawyer Leon Pomerance (June 3)



Go to results

Christopher C. Edwards

Christopher C. Edwards

Griffin Judicial Circuit Superior Court Judge

Nominated by Griffin Superior Court Chief Judge Paschal A. English; Griffin Superior Court Judges Johnnie L. Caldwell Jr. and Tommy R. Hankinson; Griffin District Attorney Scott Ballard; Griffin Public Defender Joseph J. Saia; Fayette County State Court Judge W. Fletcher Sams; State Sen. Ronnie Chance, R-Tyrone; State Reps. David Knight, R-Griffin, Virgil Fludd, D-Tyrone, Matthew L. Ramsey, R-Peachtree City, John Yates, R-Griffin, and Billy Maddox, R-Cairo; Fayette County Solicitor Jamie Inagawa, Spalding County Solicitor Griffin E. Howell III, Fayette County Attorney Scott Bennett; Spalding County Attorney James R. Fortune Jr.; Pike County Attorney Robert Lamar Morton; Upson County Attorney Truitt A. Mallory; Meansville City Attorney Thomas H. Morton; Fayette County Commission Chairman Jack Smith; Spalding County Commission Chairman Edward Goss; Pike County Commission Chairman Doug Mangham; Upson County Commission Chairman Maurice A. Raines; Fayette County Sheriff Wayne Hannah; Spalding County Sheriff Dee Stewart; Pike County Sheriff Jimmy Thomas; Upson County Sheriff Don Peacock; and Georgia Regional Transportation Authority Board Member Alton W. Knight (May 28)



Go to results

Michael J. Bowers

Michael J. Bowers

Partner at Balch & Bingham in Atlanta

Nominated by Atlanta lawyer Henry A. Hibbert (June 3)

Declined nomination



Go to results

S. Phillip Brown

S. Phillip Brown

Macon Circuit Superior Court Judge

Nominated by retired teacher Frankie Brule (June 3)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

Elizabeth P. Archer

Elizabeth P. Archer

State Inspector General

Nominated by Michelle M. Rothenberg-Williams, partner at Balch & Bingham in Atlanta (June 3)



Go to results

Rocco E. Testani

Rocco E. Testani

Litigation partner at Sutherland Asbill & Brennan in Atlanta

Nominated by Charles T. Lester Jr., of counsel at Sutherland (June 3)



Go to results

Cheryl F. Custer

Cheryl F. Custer

Executive Director of the Judicial Qualifications Commission

Nominated by Frank Love Jr. of Bryan Cave Powell Goldstein (June 3)



Go to results

George P. Shingler

George P. Shingler

Shareholder at Casey Gilson in Atlanta

Nominated by his law partner, Joyce Gist Lewis (June 4)



Go to results

Marc A. Mallon

Marc A. Mallon

Assistant District Attorney in Fulton County

Nominated by Atlanta attorney S. Fenn Little Jr. (June 4)



Go to results

Laurens C. Lee

Laurens C. Lee

Byron City Judge and Peach County Magistrate

Nominated by his brother, Louis B. Lee (June 4)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

David F. Guldenschuh

David F. Guldenschuh

Attorney in Rome

Nominated by Michelle S. Tyree, paralegal at Guldenschuh & Associates (June 4)



Go to results

Anne Proffitt Dupre

Anne Proffitt Dupre

Law professor at the University of Georgia

Nominated by Kellie Casey Monk, director of advocacy at the University of Georgia School of Law (June 4)

Declined the nomination.



Go to results

Alvin L. Bridges Jr.

Alvin L. Bridges Jr.

Managing attorney for automobile insurer in Atlanta

Nominated himself (June 4)



Go to results

Lynn M. Akeley-Alderman

Lynn M. Akeley-Alderman

Enotah Judicial Circuit Superior Court Judge

Nominated by Josh Turner, chairman of the White County Republican Party (June 4)



Go to results

Erica L. Woodford

Erica L. Woodford

Bibb County Associate Judge and Magistrate

Nominated by Macon lawyer Stephanie Woods Miller (June 4)



Go to results

Dana J. Norman

Dana J. Norman

Assistant District Attorney in Cobb County

Nominated by Atlanta lawyer Michael P. Davis of Chamberlain, Hrdlicka, White, Williams & Martin (June 3)



Go to results

Reader Results

Samuel D. Ozburn
 
71 votes / 2 percent
Garland R. Hunt
 
17 votes / 0 percent
Benjamin W. Studdard III
 
89 votes / 2 percent
Patrick H. Head
 
92 votes / 2 percent
C. Wilson DuBose
 
41 votes / 1 percent
Thomas D. Harper
 
42 votes / 1 percent
Craig L. Schwall Sr.
 
57 votes / 2 percent
William M. Ray II
 
75 votes / 2 percent
J. David McDade
 
742 votes / 20 percent
James P. Kelly III
 
5 votes / 0 percent
Stephen B. Farrow
 
12 votes / 0 percent
Mary E. Staley
 
39 votes / 1 percent
Peggy H. Walker
 
15 votes / 0 percent
Cynthia J. Becker
 
79 votes / 2 percent
M. Yvette Miller
 
26 votes / 1 percent
David E. Nahmias
 
121 votes / 3 percent
Kenneth L. Shigley
 
224 votes / 6 percent
Bruce M. Edenfield
 
18 votes / 0 percent
James R. Osborne
 
14 votes / 0 percent
Michael P. Boggs
 
16 votes / 0 percent
Stephen Louis A. Dillard
 
231 votes / 6 percent
Jeannette L. Little
 
21 votes / 1 percent
John K. Larkins Jr.
 
17 votes / 0 percent
Barry A. Fleming
 
2 votes / 0 percent
Richard S. “Rick” Thompson
 
5 votes / 0 percent
David Ralston
 
25 votes / 1 percent
William G. Hamrick III
 
3 votes / 0 percent
Joshua C. Bell
 
17 votes / 0 percent
J. Robert Persons
 
5 votes / 0 percent
Dawn H. Taylor
 
80 votes / 2 percent
Christopher J. McFadden
 
50 votes / 1 percent
Steven K. Leibel
 
6 votes / 0 percent
Christopher C. Edwards
 
89 votes / 2 percent
Michael J. Bowers
 
8 votes / 0 percent
S. Phillip Brown
 
1 votes / 0 percent
Elizabeth P. Archer
 
30 votes / 1 percent
Rocco E. Testani
 
69 votes / 2 percent
Cheryl F. Custer
 
15 votes / 0 percent
George P. Shingler
 
172 votes / 5 percent
Marc A. Mallon
 
16 votes / 0 percent
Laurens C. Lee
 
3 votes / 0 percent
David F. Guldenschuh
 
627 votes / 17 percent
Anne Proffitt Dupre
 
46 votes / 1 percent
Alvin L. Bridges Jr.
 
4 votes / 0 percent
Lynn M. Akeley-Alderman
 
10 votes / 0 percent
Erica L. Woodford
 
55 votes / 1 percent
Dana J. Norman
 
358 votes / 10 percent

Total votes = 3762